I deleted my old, good review. I used to really like Moonlight, but recently was disappointed. We called and ordered a pan of Mostaccioli for carryout. Got it home, it was cold in the middle. The pan was not even half full, and there wasn't enough sauce to cover the pasta. I'm highly dissatisfied; apparently, this place isn't what it used to be.
OVERALL
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 04/17/09
I placed a take out order that they failed to have ready even two hours after it was promised. I'll never make the mistake of trusting them again ...with take out or anything else! Be very careful of doing business with this place.
OVERALL
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 02/12/09
I would like to tell you of their shady catering. I book a room at Moonlight for a surprise birthday party. They showed me the nice room plenty of room. On the day of the event we were put into the smaller room. If that wasnt bad enough we had to pass our own drinks and food down to each other because our server wasn't able to get between ...
SHOW FULL REVIEW
OVERALL
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 10/19/08
What happen to the Restaurant it is closed and I have no-way to find out if it will reopen. Does anyone know any of the Waitresses that works there and do they have an email address that I can write to? One that I remember was Marlena janedoe413
OVERALL
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 08/20/08
From a former employee's point of view, I rate the place poor because the owners and his sons are real jerks that think they have some kind of godly authority over you as their employee. Their food is good in my opinion but they need to treat their employees much better and with with respect. One of the owner's son stays drunk all evening ...
SHOW FULL REVIEW
OVERALL
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 12/29/07
The food, service, employess & the castelli family make dining at moonlight like no other dining experience...Perfecto. We just had a rehersal dinner at moonlight and it was out of this world! The food was to die for! Moonlight also catered my friends reception last week and the food was just as good as if you would have dined in. If you have ...
2 of 2 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
SHOW FULL REVIEW
OVERALL
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 09/29/07
I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT. My daughter (the bride) and groom and her parents were very disappointed with many things about the evening of the wedding reception of 9/8/07. We wrote a letter to Moonlight several weeks ago about those items that were not up to par and they have not responded yet. The service was slow, there was not ...
0 of 1 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
SHOW FULL REVIEW
OVERALL
Consistently Good Food and Service on our 3d visit
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 06/30/07
Moonlight is like taking a mini-trip into the country, with its rural setting outside of Alton. The house salad dressing was excellent as was the pork chop. We could only finish part of the generous portion of fried chicken, which was also delicious-the rest will be lunch tomorrow. Our server, E, was helpful, friendly, and informative. Nice decor. We will be back again.
Now here is a great place to go for the very best prime rib in the state of ILL". Joe & Hazel Matich
OVERALL
Go Back to the old
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 02/21/06
I agree with everyone else. Moonlight has been a family tradition since Feb 14, 1979 when my parents had their wedding reception there. I am now 26 married with my own children. My father passed away in 1999 and I've made one effort to go back there. I was not too pleased. The whole place has undergone subltle change. I liked it the way it was. The pasta, the bread, all of it.