Also see: United States | Wisconsin
<< To Tomaso's Italian AmericanTomaso's Italian American - Reviews
Been here before?
Yahoo! User Reviews
AVERAGE OVERALL USER RATING
-
Consistently good. Love the Deep Dish. Right up there with Gino's East and some of the premier Chicago Pizza places.OVERALL
-
I would not say this was the best pizza. It was good, but not awesome. It had hardly any cheese on it, which is a much bigger problem than the rude attitude of the worker that took the order.OVERALL
-
the best thin crust I've ever had, by far. If you want to be smoozed by the bartenders this isn't the place for you. If you want good food come and get it. I miss being able to eat here more often, as I have moved to GA where I have yet to find a comparable pizza.OVERALL
-
Absolutely horrible service. The locals say this is the best pizza place, and that the owners and staff's "cocky attitude" is part of it's charm.
Their food is mediocre. Nothing special at all. Any other Italian place can make it just as good, no actually a LOT better.
I've never seen people get such a thrill out of ...SHOW FULL REVIEW
OVERALL
-
I found this little treasure tucked into the quaint town of Cedarburg my first time traveling from Milwaukee to Cedar Creek settlement. I found the pizza fantastic, as well as the fact you can have a dining experience with no bother of waitstaff. Yes it is a bit small, and tables are together quite close, but I too love the pizza and the appetizers ...SHOW FULL REVIEWOVERALL
-
Don't know how this place is still in business. Food is average. Owner is rude and the food takes forever to come out. When my brother found a hair in his sandwich the owner gave a lame excuse and refused to replace it.
The decor is old and dirty. Don't waste your time.OVERALL -
I tried the thin crust pizza years ago and loved it so much that I haven't had anything else on the menu. The pizza is great. I would eat there everyday if I could.
The restaurant itself is cramped and dimly lit. The restaurant was full one day and we had to sit at one of the middle tables and it was terrible. People bump into you because ...SHOW FULL REVIEWOVERALL
-
Horrible Pizza: This is the second time we tried. Last time was just as bad. I regret trying it again. Don't waste your money here.
Pros: Nothing really
Cons: Bad food poor serviceOVERALL -
the bartender didn't even care i was there and was helping other people when i was waiting first. not a friendly staff, won't go backOVERALL
-
bad experienceI cant argue, the food is good, but the service and the atmosphere inside is the worst I have ever seen in a restaurant, it's tiny and you have to serve yourself. Also if you go make sure you get all your food as soon as it's called or someone else will take it, than you have two dinners and a five year old who's sad because the table next to you stole his hamburger.OVERALL
