I really like Stillwater Grill. IMO the prices are a little high. And for that reason I only go 1-2 times a year ($15 to upper 20s for steaks). But when I do, I look forward very much to the steaks, fish, and garlic mashed potatos.
Get there a little early or a little late to get a table. Show up at prime time and you'll wait.

Great food, but inconsistent at times. Service is also inconsistent. Great ambiance, though, and love sitting outside in the summertime!

The Best in Town,try the Long Island Iced Tea, Steak tips or the Gusher

The food is excellent. The prices are a little steep, but if you can afford it, its worth it!

While I have enjoyed most of their menu, their prices are too high. The prices reflect a high-dining experience, but the atmosphere is more casual than that. I've had some very good meals here and have also had some not so good meals here, so I have mixed reviews on Stillwater Grill. I am very happy that they have gone smoke-free. That is a huge bonus for me continuing my patronage here.

My favorite place in Brighton. My wife and I have eaten there many times with friends and family. Service is always great and so is the food. I would definitely recommend going there.

I've been to Stillwater a couple of times. The food is average, similar to Applebee's or another chain restaurant. The service was very good but both times I had to wait 20 minutes to get a table and then the table was next to the kitchen. They do not take reservations for parties under 8. It's a large restaurant and tends to be ...

Stillwater makes great food and has a real nice atmosphere. A little expensive but worth it. Nice beer selection too. I can see why it has won the award for best restaurant in the county for some 7 years.

The cajun tendeloin tips are so good I have a hard time ordering anything else.