Also see: United States | Indiana
<< To Polito's Pizzeria RestaurantPolito's Pizzeria Restaurant - Reviews
Been here before?
Yahoo! User Reviews
AVERAGE OVERALL USER RATING
-
Wow what a breakthru !!!!! great selection and the best salad bar I have ever had anywhere !! all fresh and good !!!! their prices are well withing bounds and the quality and quantity are superb. the selection of alcoholic beverages are fantastic == SUPER JOB they have done since their fire == so GLAD TO HAVE THEM BACK !!! as good if not better ...SHOW FULL REVIEW
OVERALL
-
Food and service are still very good. Although since the move after the fire they no longer serve beer and wine! Their also seem's to be no urgency to continue serving alcohol again. With so many choices for great Italian food in this area I find myself going down the street for dinner and wine!OVERALL
-
Polito's was my favorite pizzeria in St. Joseph County. The atmosphere, as well as the food, made going here a truly fun experience. Their pizza is the best in this area and they always made us feel like family.
On behalf of my family, I want give the Polito family our condolences, and our thoughts go out to you.3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulOVERALL -
GOOD STUFF ! the stuffed pizza slices are great. the beer cold the service good. (And overall its cheaper then "O-live" Garden and ya can smoke if ya like. Great place!3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulOVERALL
-
My husband picked me up from work on his Goldwing GL 1800 for lunch one day. The trip to Mishawaka is around 1 hr. away. We had a little bit of shopping to do, we decided to eat somewhere before we left Mishawaka. He asked where, I told him it didn't matter. We passed Polito's and just as we were driving by, he spotted it. He asked if I ...3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulSHOW FULL REVIEWOVERALL
-
This place is EXCELLENT! I'm suprised no one has mentioned their vodka sauce, that is by far my favorite thing from there! So YUMMY! Prices are very reasonable too! I go sometimes for lunch and spend less than I would at McDonalds!3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulOVERALL
-
Great restaurant. My husband and I often share the penne graciala. The portions are huge! Their breadsticks are terrific-- garlicy and buttery. I am also a fan of the spinach stuffed shells. My husband also enjoys the chicken parmagiana The food is always hot, cheesy, and yummy. The one critique I have of the restaurant is the service. It ...2 of 2 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulSHOW FULL REVIEWOVERALL
-
Great New York Style PizzaProbably the best hand tossed pizza I've found outside of NYC. Tied with Brunos, in my opinion, for the best pizza in the area. I always make it in whenever I'm back in town for some reason. Service is always friendly and the atmosphere is pretty nice, as well.3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulOVERALL
-
Share your order peopleI'm 6', over 200 lbs, and I can't even eat half of a slize of stuffed pizza by myself.
They won't sell you half a slice, so pick a piece with a friend and share it, or you'll end up crawling home.
Really good, fantastic value.2 of 2 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulOVERALL -
Wish you were closer!I live in Illinois and have a summer home 15 miles north of Politos. I grew up in NY and left there 30 years ago. I had never lost my taste for NY style pizza and never quite found it till last year when I came across Politos. Their slice and square as referred to by most NY-ers, is the best I have tasted, even better than some NY pizzerias. I go there as often as possible. They have the best Calzones I have ever had, even while in NY.4 of 4 Yahoo! Users found this review helpfulOVERALL
