My Husband and I had dinner outside, nice views, we ordered the shrimp platter and Grouper.
I was very disapointed in the Grouper, it was wet inside, and fishy, not sure if it was grouper, my husband never complains and thought the shrimp breading was not very good, not good flavor.The cold slaw was the worst! We will NOT be returning. We hardly go out to dinner and what a waste of money.

Nice little restaurant. I wouldn't recommend any of the quesadillas but the conch fritters were out of this world.

Wow! What a place! So we figured the best thing to do is get the freshest fish and nothing off the menu. Great choice! Got the conch fritters as our starter. Never had conch before and I totally enjoyed them. Heard that conch can be chewy, but these fritters were yum. The rice that came with the fish was a little bland, but I chalked that up ...

We stopped in the Island Fish Company for a late lunch/early dinner. I have to start by saying that the Restaurant is lovely. Great location and excellent staff. Our waiter couldn't have been nicer. With that said, the food was just terrible. I have never eaten a meal where all three courses had absolutely no taste. I started with the Potato ...

The island atmosphere of this place is great. Sits right on the water, outside dining, tiki roof, island music, etc. However, the place is CRAZY busy! We waited an hour for dinner on a Wednesday night. The wait staff runs around in a constant scurry. The food we got was good. I got the shrimp platter, came with fries and coleslaw. Nothing unusual, ...

Okay, seriously - anyone who has posted a review of less than 4 or 5 stars is really just wrong - or grumpy/extremely high maintenance. Where could you possibly be eating if you're eating a better meal elsewhere in the middle Keys? Please, those who do not like The Island ... enlighten me ... I've eaten at every restaurant in the Keys, ...

This is BY FAR the best restaurant in the middle keys. I've been coming to the Keys every winter holiday for years now, and I can personally guarantee you that you won't get a better meal (with fast service - which we all know isn't the most common in these parts ... lol ... ) anywhere else.
The food is exceptional. Their conch ...

Don't waist your time or money. Ok for sunset and a cold beverage. Last time I went there I tried a more "fancy" seafood dish and it was expensive, so-so and cold. This time I tried a grouper basket- hard to messup- I thought. I really doubt that it was grouper and it was lousy!!!!! Overpriced, long wait too. Our kids had chicken quesadillas they were good.

My husband and I ate here in 1/08. The wait staff was nice, the place had a fun atmosphere but the food was just ok. My hubby had the blackened snapper and he enjoyed it. I had coconut shrimp and it was ok. The only dipping sauce that offered with it was cocktail or tarter which doesn't go well with coconut. Conch fritter appetizers were ...