Saturday night dinner at 6 PM was fine. I do not understand the April 20, 2009 review. The dinner fare, coconut shrimp and the trio seafood platter were very good. The waiter was prompt. attentive and friendly. The atmosphere is nothing to write home about but it certainly was clean and fresh, but who is eating atmosphere? Compare it to a ...

"Barnacle Bills: A step outside the realm of time"

First off, while in St. Augustine, never ask the Information Center for advice on where to eat. They will instantly point you in the direction of Barnacle Bills because it is the closest seafood restaurant to them and it will take them the least amount of time to explain how to get ...

This place was nasty. The service was terrible & I ordered something very simple (salmon) and received fish that was nowhere near fresh. I was served rice that had obviously been sitting under a heat lamp for hours. The onion rings that came with the dish could have been rung out, they were so greasy. I sent it back. Since my appetite was instantly ...

I went there for a dinner on a Saturday evening. Delicious!!! I am a big lover of seafood and I would highly recommend this place to everyone.

Absolutely the worst seafood I have ever eaten. My wife and I had a late lunch there on 11-23-2007, after arriving in St Augustine and being told this was the place to go. After waiting over half an hour for a table...we were seated, and placed our order. My wife ordered the fried shrimp and I ordered the fried softshell crab. It took almost an ...

What a great restaurant! If you love seafood as much as I do, you will not disappointed here. The food was great, portions were plentiful, prices were reasonable and the wait staff was friendly! What more could you ask for. . . .oh, and the hush puppies. . . are the bomb! Best I have ever eaten!

It was our first time to dine there. We mostly ordered shrimp plates and they were very good. The waitress was very polite.
The place was clean and good atmosphere. I believe we will keep coming back in the future.