Love this little place, it was our second visit. The food is fabulous, great Tomato basil soup too. The staff efficient and friendly. The restaurant was clean and neat, however can't say the same for the bathrooms. We sat by the window, which would have been more pleasant if the blinds and windows panes were clean and dust free. The front of ...

favoritr local resteraunt!!! paulys has the absolut best soups and the florintine is to die for!!! erics awsome!!!

We lived in St Marys when Pauly's had just opened ... to this day, it is STILL my most favorite place to eat of all time. The food is great, the service is great, and the prices are SUPREME :)

It is worth a trip to St. Marys just to eat at Pauly's. My tuna entree was superb......one of the best meals I had in 2006.

You will not b-e-l-i-e-v-e the incredible food Chef Eric Haugen creates....at ANY price. Yet he consistently prepares sumptuous delights so reasonably priced one could "eat like a king" seven days a week. Bring your appetite! The pastas--especially the Carbonara, the Vongole and the Lasagna--are piled high and so expertly seasoned you ...

Pauly's may look like a quaint Italian cafe located in a historic coastal town-but it boasts dishes that would rival any five star restaurant. Be sure to order a bottle of wine to accompany the crab stuffed mushrooms, savory chicken marsala with roasted potatoes, or my favorite--the amazing almond crusted grouper. And please--don't leave ...