Food is good. place is nice along with the people. My only complaint is the menu. it is too big. while that sounds strange it just seemed to me the place would be better if they did not try to cook as many dishs. If they stayed focused on just half that menu i think it would be a lot better.

I'm from NY, which obviously influences my judgement. :-)
The four stars are based on what's good there, not overall:
As long as you're NOT getting something with a red sauce, the food is very good. Their calamari is among the best I've ever had!
Decent salad bar.
Good service, although slow (but that's possibly my NY ...

Five star Italian food. Although it may not be the place to go for pizza, my out of town friends (especially New Yorkers and Italians) compare Joe and Mimma's to their best back home. Reservations are essential on weekends...Favorites? Their fresh fish and scallop dishes are supreme!

Only Fair, I agree the salad bar is good. The pizza and food is mediocre by real Italian standards. I think I can say that because both my husband and I are Italian. Frank's and Nonni's are much better especially for Pizza.

This restaurant has the best most authenic italian food in town. Salad bar is great and they have smaller portions of entrees at lunch time. It is kid friendly too. All the pasta dishes are great the plan to get a take home box or go there very hungry if you go for the veal dishes at dinner. Great place for couples, singles, and families.

THE FOOD IS WONDERFUL AND THE SALAD BAR IS THE BEST IN TOWN.