We stopped at the Island Creamery on our way home from dinner at AJ's. The blueberry muffin ice cream was delicious, such a huge serving for a single scoop! My husband had the maple walnut ice cream and it was the smoothest I had tasted in a long time. We will go back during our next visit to the island.

I would drive 5 1/2 hours just to visit the Island Creamery!!! It is THE BEST ice cream I've EVER had! If you're a chocolate lover like me, you must try "Marsh Mud!" It is deeeeeeeeeeeeee-licious!!! :)

This is the BEST ice cream ever in the history of ice cream! My family and I went there and the service was great, the people who worked there were really nice! The flavors were VERY rich. Our family of 5 got the "round up" and it filled us up. I hope you try it!!

This Ice Cream is the BEST ice cream ever!!! Me and my family are from Michigan and we try to get out there every two to three years. When we do go on vacation we go there every single night we are there. Yes the lines can be long sometimes but they move rather quickly, and the service is A++++. The Island Creamery is a must go to if in the area.

This was the best icecream i've ever had. They have homemade icecream, homemade wafflecones, and homemade fudge! If you ever visit Chincoteague you have to try this place!

This ice cream is really great. I went with my class for school!