Some of the best pizza around. Highly recommend!!

owner must have sold to new people and did not give them the recipe. I went there for over 20 years and it was the best around. Twice the pie was thick crusted, spotty burnt and yet undercooked. Don't bother there are better places now. I am sad to see Colosseo deteriorate so much.

Best pizza in the area. Always busy, thus always fresh slices. A good slice of pizza consistently.

The best pizza anywhere. If you want good pizza, this is it. If you want the best, quietest experience, then don't go on a Friday night. It's a little hectic to say the least. But the pizza makes the craziness worth it. Go during the week, or on a Sunday for lunch. You'll get good service and the best pizza.

Delicous! Ever since I've been born I have gone to Colosseo. Everything is great there. The best garlic knots I have ever tasted and I have tasted alot of garlic knots. I also have to say that the Sicilian Pizza has all the right components to a perfect Sicilian. It has a buttery-flakey crust, red ripe tomato sauce and tons of mozzarella chesse. The best pizza place on Long Island and maybe New York.

THE BEST... 20+ years of consistency. Nothing comes close. Stop reading reviews, shut down the PC and go get a slice of white..DO IT NOW.

The best stuffed pizza in the area at a good price.

the best pizza anywhere,hands-down. I grew up on colosseo's and stop there every time i go back to LI to visit.I live in PA now and nothing here comes close! as far as the bad reviews,to each is own.
i never had a problem with service there,and the food is always excellent.

THEY HAVE THE BEST PIZZA IN NY! THE CARLO FAMILY FROM EAST SETAUKET LOVES THIS PLACE! YUMMY! KEEP ON MAKING THOSE PIES THE WAY WE LOVE THEM. YOU GUY'S ARE 5 STAR IN MY BOOK! THANKS, CIAO, THE CARLO FAMILY