I have been going to Tony's for 40 years. Eventhough ownership has changed several times over the years, it is by far the best pizza around. I also go to LaScala in Commack. LaScala does have very good pies and variety, but when it comes down to an old fashion pizzeria and a neapolitan pie, Tony's is #1!!!!!

I don't know what restaurant 'Brentwood Native' is talking about?! Tony's Pizza is by far the BEST on the Island. I've moved away and have to drive 13 hours to get there now, but it's well worth it!

As a Brentwood native and still here I must say I am no longer a customer the pizza is never consistent. Just not my or my family's choice anymore. Especially since Vinny and family sold out. Tony's need's to step it up and give better choices and deals. My choice is La-Scala.

Truly the best pizza shop on Long Island. Priced just right for excellent quality foods. It has been my family's tradition for every reunion on the first night we are home to buy pies from Tony's. They even know my grandmother by first name!

Tony's has been a family tradition from since I was born. No matter how far we moved we all made trips back for Tony's Pizza. You will not leave dissatisfied, whether dinning in the restaurant or just getting a slice, you will be happy and full. They are priced right with great portions. Do yourself a favor and give them a try!!

Can't complain food is good and so are the prices.