I honestly never would of went into it but i wantedto try it after the renovation and was extremly surprised. Had the porterhouse steak and if was tender and very tasty. Good winelist and it was a pleasent experience. Would recomend it to anyone in the area.

I went to see a Broadway play, and a meal here was included with my ticket. This was the worst dining experience I've ever had. The staff was pushy, easily confused, and not very accomplished in the English language. We had to walk through the kitchen to get to our table - something any health inspector would surely frown upon. The waterboy ...

I know that sounds dramatic but the service was gruff and pretentious.I've been to many of the steakhouses in town and was shocked by the callous nature of the waitstaff.

The review dated 10/3/2005 is suspiciously glowing. I ate at Broadway Joe a few days after eating at the Wollensky Grill so I can compare the two. In terms of the quality of the steak--not even close. Wollensky, a top steak house, was light years ahead. But Broadway Joe was respectable, if a bit overpriced. I had lunch--and $27 bought a steak, a ...