Same as it ever was with the exception of some newer booths and the addition of some Televisions. Fitzy is not there anymore (that I know of) he would be around 90 something? He certainly was an interesting waiter/fixture taking orders of small and large tables without writing a thing down, and nailing it correctly every time.

Great Pizza, a must go to eatery......

This used to be the best place for pizza. The new owner has fired the best waiter and removed all memories of the good 'ole days. If you remember Bo & Fitzy this place is NOT anything like when they were around. It's been redecorated and now there's big oversized booths so there is no room to move when it's crowded. Although, if ...

After all the hard work and dedication that Tommy & his Father (Fitzy) gave to Bo and the Colony (almost 70 years combined), it's a shame that the new owner terminated Tommy the way he did. Oh wait! The owner didn't even give Tommy the respect to discuss the matter with him directly - he had somenoe else do his dirty work! Everything that was unique and special about the Colony is now gone.

What do you mean Tommy (Fitzy's son) was fired. Are they stupid!!?? As it is the place has lost all its charm...just another yuppy bore! Won't be going back

I HAVE BEEN GOING TO THE COLONY GRILL FOR OVER THIRTY YEARS; I WILL NEVER GO BACK AGAIN !
MY FAMILY AND I WENT ON OUR USUALLY FRIDAY NIGHT TO FIND OUT THE NEW OWNERS HAVE FIRED THE BEST WAITER (TOMMY "FITZY JR.") BECAUSE OF HIS " BAD ATTITUDE" THE REPLACEMENT WAS RUDE, SERVICE WAS SLOW THE PIZZA WAS TERRIBLE. WE HAVE WAITED ...

This pizza is wonderful. Thin crust is the best. The hot oil pizza is not to be missed.

This place always has somewhat of a crowd. They dont take credit cards. They only make pizza. The service is bad. The pizza takes forever to get to you. You eat off of paper plates and use brown rough napkins. Then you get the pizza, and it is always one of the most amazing pies ever. This place consistantly cranks out great pizza. I go with regular cheese or the stinger pie. Definitly 100% worth trying.

Yup, it is that good. Unfortunately the prices went up, but we still return.

Very good pizza! Fun atmosphere, any pizza you order is very good. They are all thin crust, and one size, just a bit bigger than a personal pizza (which gives everyone a bit to take home!). Got to try it!