I used to go there 1-2 times a month & the place always had a line a the door. The last night we went there was no line.We waited a few minutes to be seated & almost 15 minutes till we recieved a menu.
My wife & I usually order a all meat pie & a eggplant pie & bring half of each home for the rest of the family.
When the pies came out, the 1st ...

After hearing from many people that Modern Pizza serves the best pizzas anywhere, my wife and I decided to try it out. What a terrible disappointment! The pie was soggy and watery in the center, and the sauce had no taste at all. The only saving grace on the pie was that the sausage was tasty. This place is not worth the trip to New Haven from anywhere!

probably overall , the best apizza in the world . and if not pretty darn close !
actually since i have not had all the pizza in the world as of yet , i may be stretching the truth a tad .
lets say , you would be very hard pressed to find better thin crust italian style apizza far and wide !

My family has been going to Modern probably since before I was born. Modern is probably the best pizza I've ever had

Modern ranks third on my list.Sally's Zuppardi's,Modern.when you leave you need to drink a gallon of water.

I have to disagree and put this ahead of pepe's and sally's. This is #1 in my book.. This is the Gold Standard when it comes to pizza in my opinion.

in my opinion - finishes 3rd to pepe's and sally's in any other city this would be first
the big diference is their clam pizza (my favorite) is no where near as good as the other 2

Modern is defiantly a 5 Star Restaurant, great food there.

awesome pizza, best i have had in new haven out of sallys, modern, and pepes