The only people giving Mystic Pizza rave and great reviews are the people who works there plus the owners. Then their friends & relatives.

Trust me, do not waste your time & money on their pizza. Maybe try their burgers or BLT or something. Those may be better (but we did not try those). The pizza was garbage.

GROSS! Do not eat here! It had the strangest taste ever! My wife eats anything and she even threw hers in the garbage! Greasy, slimy and taste like dish soap!
DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME!

Mystic pizza is a big mistake. Pizza was greasy & soggy. Lousy pizza. The 49 cents a slice pizza at Costco or Sam's club is better than this junk. It actually taste like frozen pizza that got placed in an oven.

Go to Sally's or Pepe's pizzeria in New Haven instead. Pepe's will be in Yonkers NY soon and they have branches in ...

Yuk. Pie was small. Price was high. Paid $37 for a "large" pie and chicken parm with 2 pieces of chicken. Only ate it for the nostalgia. Won't be ordering from there again.

been there ... tried it. LOVED it ... am going top make a trip and go again!!!!

Mystic Pizza is truly a delight. Being from Brooklyn, NY I am hard to please when it comes to pizza.
We went there on a snowy weekend in February.
The waitress was friendly and attentive. The antipast salad was enormous and delicious. The sampler platter was tasty and the pizza was excellent!!!! I would definitely make the trip back to Mystic for another slice of heaven!

My girlfriend & I were travelling from Brooklyn, NY to New London, CT to
see a show at the Garde Theatre (beautiful venue!) and we had a choice
of stopping @ Frank Pepe's (in New Haven) or going to Mystic Pizza.
Now I knew that Pepe's was going to be better no matter what, but
we thought we would give Mystic Pizza a try (so my girl can ...

I live in Rhode Island and have been wanting to go to Mystic Pizza ever since I saw the movie. I finally went after taking my kids to the Mystic Aquarium, and the pizza was disappointing. The service was good, the restaurant was big and nicely decorated with photos of movie stars on the walls. They even had a gift shop to buy overpriced hats and T ...

Mystic Pizza is just there to run off the fame of the movie. The locals don't even eat there because the pizza is horrible. You can always see a tourist standing there in front of the Mystic Pizza sign getting their photo taken. You're better off just taking the photo and telling people you ate there. Go somewhere else.