The Inn at StoneCliffe, Mackinac Island

We had dinner at the Sirloin & Saddle Restaurant at the Inn at StoneCliffe on Saturday night, July 19, 2008, with a reservation at 8:15. The principal problem was understaffing. They had two waiters handling all of the tables, taking orders, clearing, serving food, etc. Other tables were complaining. A guest at one table finally walked out, although his companions remained. We just did a slow burn. Management knew they were in over their heads. We were offered mild apologies, politely accepted, and a free glass of wine or free desserts, politely declined. Ultimately our tab was voluntarily discounted 20 percent. The whole meal should have been comped. Foodwise, my wife said her filet mignon was very good, while my bone-in ribeye was way overdone and more like saddle than sirloin. The wine list is brief, mostly mediocre and overpriced. The restaurant manager actually served our wine, amateurishly. I could go on, but why bother. For the money, this was the worst restaurant experience I've had in my 66 years. On the plus side the location, although about a 45 min. cab ride (horse-drawn) from the downtown harbor area, is very nice and the Inn and dining room themselves are attactive.

Worth every penny and then some. Sunset from the "rock" was spectacular. Away from all the hustle & bustle of downtown. Being right acrcoss the street from the golf course is a nice little plus too.

I like the fact is was clean new and had good amenities. if you don't stay in the mansion you have ac, a microwave. great breakfasts. its like the experience of the grand. great view. and the pool bar has good food for dinner. at a good price. only problem is, is that it is far away from town. but with the price and all the other great stuff I didn't care.

We have been going to Mackinaw Is. every year for the past 10 years. The last 3 years we have stayed at the Stonecliff Inn. THis is a great place to stay. They have a variety of rooms to choose from. THe grounds are spacious and it's off the beaten path. But you still can ride your bike or take the taxi back into the town. The staff is great. We have had a great time each year on the Island and we love going back to Stonecliff. Highly recommended.