Also see: United States | New York
Shelter Island Hotels (6)
SORT BY:
1
Don't bother to stay anywhere ...
by A Yahoo! Contributor
This is my very favorite place in our country & I have been everywhere. Sherry is my favorite hostess of the Island!! Best view in New England!! ... more
2
Can't wait to go back
by A Yahoo! Contributor
Beautiful old Home, great grounds, amazing breakfast, Carol and Callie were a complete delight to wake up and have breakfast with, friendly and ... more
3
Disappointed
by A Yahoo! Contributor
My wife and I stayed at the Pridwin to take a break from our 2 year old son. The whole point was to relax and sleep in. The area is great, the rooms are ... more
Hotel Class: 
4
Will Never go back
by steven j
We have never checked in and checked out so fast. The quaint Inn supplied an Army of flies in the room. A bathroom that quickly wiped down at best. Go ... more
| Nearby Cities | Block Island, RI (47.7 miles) | Providence, RI (73.9 miles) | Mystic, CT (28.9 miles) | Newport, RI (68.4 miles) | New Haven, CT (40.2 miles) |
|---|
Yahoo! Travel: Your best choice for cheap hotels and other great deals!