Beware the restaurant
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 1/22/08
PROS
THe rooms are huge. The service is exceptional. The front desk staff and all the restaurant staff work very hard to make everything worry-free for you.
The pool is beautiful and the view from the pool even more beautiful.
If you are considering staying at La Mansion Inn, make sure you get one of the rooms on the upper level (better view), and, if you can swing it get the Penthouse.
CONS
La Mansion Inn is trapped in a bit of a time warp when it comes to decor. Sorta reminded me of The Madonna Inn in San Luis Obispo, CA (but I don't think it means to). I think its heydey was some time in the early 80s, judging by the photos donning the lobby walls replete with then-big celebs and dignitaries.
We were there for 7 days around New Years holiday. Only ate at the hotel once.
The food was in our opinion, horrific. I ordered a chicken dish stuffed with spinach and shrimp (which is weird enough, I guess). But there was no spinach to speak of, and the shrimp tasted weeks old and like it had gone off. My bet is the simpler dishes like steak and grilled fish are fine, but they try so hard to make the restaurant "fancy" experience, that they seem to have forgotten about the food.
Example of strange features: two large-screen TVs playing old video of Andrea Bocelli concert, followed by an even weirder video of Sarah Brightman dancing around like a Moroccan gyspy. Who wants to watch TV while they're eating?
And the decor in the restaurant is equally, er, eclectic. Statues of jousting horses, undersea photography, and huge ornate chandeliers, and, my favorite feature, the dancing inflatable snowman and Santa right outside the windows.
To conclude: try to avoid eating there, except breakfast (which is GREAT!!!). There are looads of good restaurants in the area.
Oh, and don't rent a car either. you won't need it. Cabs are everywhere and cheap (by NYC standards).
Lastly, It's a 4-star hotel in CR, but in US would probably get 3.