I Stay Here Often
I go to Garberville about once every 6 weeks. I always use the Garberville Motel. They welcome my dog, for a slight extra fee, and I always get a room with no door to the adjoining room, which keeps my dog calmer (not all rooms are that way, you have to ask).
The rooms are clean and comfortable and the rates are good. The ice machine always has ice and works well. I always have a cooler with food. I notice that there have always been little improvements made between my visits. It's not brand new, but I don't mind.
Although it is right off the highway, I've never noticed any noise. Also, there is an open field right across the street, which is an ideal place to walk the dog after doing some travelling. I'm usually on my way to Shelter Cove, from Sacramento, and this is an ideal stopping point.