Almost great... but yes, it IS old
As so many have said: yes, it is an old hotel. I expected a bit more style and luxury, for a top rated hotel (the furnishings were a bit scratched, the bathroom was quite small), but it is a nearly century-old building. One cannot expect perfection. I did find the staff to be quite friendly, the bellman and valets to be pleasant and prompt. I stayed for 2 nights, and ran into the housekeeping service person, who was also quite friendly. Though, I gave the "cleanliness" rating a low mark, because after the first night, she obviously made the bed and straightened the towels, but even though I followed the "green clean" request to put towels that needed to be replaced on the floor, she did not do so, and I was left with one small towel for my shower the next day, the drinking glasses were not refreshd/replaced, the ice bucket was left with a puddle of water in it, and the toilet tissue was left with a near empty roll. Perhaps part of their "green" plan is to be more frugal with such items, but it seemed a bit stingy to me (I can see not washing the sheets after one night, but a soaked wet towel on the floor should be replaced, as should toothpaste soiled plastic cups). Location wise the place is ideal: I was on a shoe-string budget for food/fun (the cost of the hotel was paid by my employer), and there were many options within walking distance of the hotel. I would, however, have liked at least ONE other option for dining within the hotel, besides the seafood restaurant. It was not so much the price (though was part of it), but as a solo traveler, dining in a sit-down white tablecloth establishment is not always the most fun, and something a bit more casual that did not require me to exit the premises alone, after dark, might have been nice (tip: if you are traveling alone, and dont like dining alone in a white-tablecloth restaurant, you will have to leave the site on foot to find ANY thing other than coffee). Lastly, as some that posted have mentioned, the price for valet service is a bit high. As an out of towner that had arrived by vehicle, I had no choice but to park, and to relegate hotel guests to either paying over $50 for 2 days ($24 a day, plus a tip or two if you take the car out), or trekking a distance from some sort of pay lot: seems a bit ridiculous (though is offset, a bit, by the room price as compared to most of the other nicer downtown hotels...I just think that, for guests, the hotel could do a better price for valet service). Overall: good service, good location, good quality for an old hotel, valet is pricey, food choices w/in the hotel are limited, and be more clear with your housekeeping staff about what you would like if you are staying multiple nights.