Scribner Hollow Lodge, Hunter

This is the worst hotel I have ever been to. I have been to many hotels around the world and Scribner Hollow Lodge is by far the worst! They are very overpriced for very poor quality. The food was OK - nothing great. The rooms were terrible - felt dusty and dirty. The Grotto wasn't even very nice - small and dark. They gave me a room that had broken air conditioning and multiple cobwebs (with spiders in them). So I had to change rooms (with 2 young kids) late at night. I had to move all of my stuff myself - they did not offer to move my bags for me! All they moved was the crib. They put me in a room that was upstairs and they don't have an elevator at their lodge. That is fine for single people, however I had a young child in a stroller. So anytime I had to go eat or wanted to leave the hotel, I had to carry my stroller down multiple sets of stairs. It was terrible! They also say they have WIFI - but it doesn't actually work in the rooms - so it's basically useless. The most important thing is that they overcharged me and they refused to refund me the money. I realized this after the bill had been paid, but they refused to fix it on the spot. They said I had to call the next day to talk to Kate who does the books. Well, when I talked to Kate she refused to refund me the money that was obviously overcharged, saying they had done me a favor by moving me out of a room with broken air conditioning to one that has AC (that was way smaller than the original room). I now have to take my time and effort to try and correct this through the credit card company! What a waste of time! I would never go to Scribner Hollow Lodge again - the place is terrible! Stay away!!!

Wow. This place is all it says it is. The pool or Groto as they call it is very cool. My kids loved it! So did my husband and myself we loved the hot tub. The staff was so nice and so accomating. The room was cozy and clean. Kate even put an air purifier in the room for my husband and son b/c of their allergies. Thanks Kate. The food was fabulous I wish I could cook flank steak like that. It was nice to see so many low calorie selections on the menu. Thank you also for allowing my son to order the duck appetizer. First time trying duck and he loved it. Compliments to you chef. Breakfast was just right also. Just enough so you weren't stuffed before hitting the slopes or the tubing lines. We had such a great time but had to cut it short b/c I wasn't feeling well and Kate offered us a credit. That wasn't necessary but was extremely nice of Scribner's to do so. The price of your meals included with the room is sooooooo worth it. The wine was awesome and the beer selection was great. There is not enough that I can say about Scribner Hollow Lodge. The staff are so nice and sincere. My waitress remembered that I wasn't feeling well Friday night when I asked for tea for my evening in the room the next moring she asked how I was feeling. And when we left she wished me better and said she was sad to see us leave early. HOw sweet, most staff wouldn't remember that. This lodge is where you want to be when you just want to get away and relax. The all took great care of us and we can't wait to go back.

Upon deciding to travel to the Catskills with some friends we chose Scribner Hollow as our lodging. We werent' sure what to expect but we were all pleasantly surprised. The staff was corteous, and attentive, the room had wonderful views and was clean and bright. It looked like it had been newly renovated. The restaurant was amazing! The food was incredilble and the wine list extensive. The staff was very knowledgeable and accomodating. The pool was a great place to relax and unwind after long days of hiking. The lounge area had a great antique wooden bar and a huge fireplace that was perfect for after our hearty dinners. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone and wouldn't think of staying somewhere else when I go back to the area.

Spent the weekend with over 50 friend and we had the place to ouor selves it was fantastic and relaxing. staff were friendly and nice.

We were treated like friends, not strangers, during our stay. This is a classic mountain lodge. The view of the mountains was awesome. The suite was very cozy and well maintained by the staff. Also, there was always enough wood for the fireplace. The entire staff from the front desk, through the lounge and into the restaurant was courteous and very friendly at all times. The menu selections were many, prepared excellently and served with a smile. Don't venture out in search of another restaurant. The meals at Scribner Hollow are 5 star. We enjoyed a very peaceful and relaxing vacation. The front desk was very helpful with directions to area attractions and suggestions. No negatives noted.

Everything was perfect... owners, staff, food, suite, pool... it felt like home. The owners and staff were friendly and made us feel like we knew them a lifetime. The food was delicious - knowing good gourmet food, this came out on top. The room had an amazing view of Hunter Mountain. The cost was high but worth it considering it was all inclusive with two meals - a great breakfast and a four-course dinner (the clams, the steak, the seabass - unbelievable) and even dessert with an extensive wine list! We cannot wait to go back to try the rest of the menu! We're making this a yearly anniversary getaway and also want to get back there as soon as possible.

My husband and I celebrated our wedding at Scribner Hollow on Columbus Day weekend, 2008. It was a second wedding for both of us, and our desire was for an intimate, special celebration for family and a handful of friends, and it was. From the beginning planning stages until the day we left, our special event was nothing but perfect. Kate and Guy Chirico are truly special people that treated us like family from day one. We cannot say enough about the service, the food and the personal treatment that we received that made us and our guests of approximately 40 people, make us feel at home. Every detail was addressed, and one or two unexpected near disaster's (unrelated to Scribner) were met by Kate especially, with utmost concern and attention. Our rooms were comfortable and well appointed (as Bride and Groom we had the Penthouse suite - amazing!) and the service lent by the other staff members was top notch and totally accomodating. Guy is a celebrated chef, and from the hor doerves that were served to the main entree's, it is easy to see why his restaurant The Prospect, has received top honors from major publications, the food is divine and well presented. The accomodating wine program was equal in perfection, and also award winning and noted in local guide publications. While the gorgeous, picturesque location could sell this place on it's own, the food and the service provided by Guy and Kate and their staff, make it a destination location to be envied by the local competition. We cannot say enough good things about our experience at Scribner, but the memories we have and the pictures of our wedding day there say it all - Perfection. Our heartfelt thanks to Guy and Kate Chirico and Staff for helping to make the most memorable days of our lives!

I thought Scribner Hollow Lodge had charm and above all catered to its clientele. It is a family-owned lodge and I felt their personal attention to detail throughout the entirety of my stay. I have a disability and they catered to my every need above and beyond what most hotels would do. The dining room had a warm and friendly atmosphere, so much so that you could visit with the people at the other tables, which I found very inviting. The staff couldn't have been more friendly or helpful. I would definitely stay there again and in fact I am thinking of a return visit in the fall to see the colors.

My fiancee and I were in search of a reception location for our Autumn 2008 wedding. Scribner Hollow was first on our list of possibilities. We booked an overnight stay in February, and were totally thrilled! We were warmly welcomed by the Lodge owner and shown to our room. Our room was spacious, and tastefully appointed in Adirondack style. It was clean, updated and the kingsize bed was totally comfortable, including large perfect pillows. The fireplace in our room was cozy, and staff even brought extra kindling and started the fire for us. Dinner was included in our reservation, as was breakfast the following morning. Both of us having traveled near and far, and my fiance having been property manager of a very famous Catskill resort for almost 20 years, we are not easily "sold" or impressed, but Scribner Hollow exceeded our expectations, especially after having read the negative reviews. Our dining experience was incredible. He chose the NY strip steak, and I had the salmon, though it was hard to make up our minds from all the fantastic choices. From presentation, to portion and taste, we had no complaints. Following our dinner, the chef/owner introduced himself and made sure we were satisfied. It is no great surprise that their restaurant has received rave reviews in local and state travel guides. The food fresh, mostly locally grown, organic, and professionaly prepared. Our selection of NY state wine perfectly accompanied our meal. We then relaxed in the Grotto, which is where the hot tub, pool and sauna is located. The hot tub was soothing, the pool refreshing, all spotless. We opted to indulge in our dessert back in our room later and the decadent chocolate dessert totally completed the evening. Breakfast was equally satisfying the following morning, with French Toast as thick as you could want, complimented with locally made maple syrup. Fresh muffins, fruit and other breakfast treats also available. Following our checkout, we were scheduled to visit another local catering site/restaurant. We didn't even bother. Scribner Hollow has all were were looking for. Perfect location (facing Hunter Mountain), outstanding food and wine, and service that we found no fault in. The owners could not have been more accomodating, and are in fact like people we've known for years. Our reception planning has been a breeze, and exciting. We look forward to posting another review after 10/08. Final word, if you are expecting the Ritz Carlton, high class theater, high price boutiques, then stay in the city. If you can't stand to be without Wifi and the thought of occasional weak cell reception scares you to death, then the Mountains are not for you. This is the COUNTRY after all. If you are a skier, or looking for a relaxing respite where you can enjoy all that NY state has to offer in the way of enjoying the great outdoors or poking around quaint shops and historic locations, all the while enjoying local ambience and fine dining, then select Scribner. Be prepared to enjoy the company you are with, let your palate be indulged, and you shouldn't be disappointed.

We came to Scribner Hollow for our honeymoon, not knowing anything about the area but now we can not wait to return to Scribner Hollow for our first anniversary! The staff was so friendly, (they made us feel like family!!!) the food - amazing - fresh and a new special everyday, the room was clean, comfortable and romantic. If you are a wine lover, you need to check out the extensive wine list!!! The staff took time to assist us with local attractions and directions to help make our honeymoon unforgetable. We did alot of research for our honeymoon the price is very competitive for all the amenities that they offer. Everything about this vacation was wonderful. I could never have asked for a better experience.