Hotel is nice, staff needs more training
This hotel is amazing and I would recommend it to anyone. Just be aware that some of the staff members don't seem to care at all about the guests. From the front desk, every request I made was met with a "no." The wait staff in the bar restaurant sometimes ignores the guests to the point that my husband and I would have to walk up to the bar and ask someone to take our order, even when we were the only people in the entire restaurant and we were in plain view of the bar waitress! Also, I had an incident where a parent was watching his children at the pool and asked me if I would request the bar staff to send a glass of water to the pool. The bar staff responded by telling me to tell him that "all he has to do is pick up the phone (by the pool)!" I told the parent what the staff said, so he went to the phone and it wasn't even working! So then he asked me to watch his kids while he went up to the bar and got a glass of water. For only 21 rooms at the hotel and for the price, wouldn't you expect more? I did. But, the hotel itself is beautiful and the island is a dream, so in a way, putting up with some of the staff was sort of worth it. Just be warned. Also, some staff memebers were great, especially the manager.
Also, be aware that the food at this lodge was very expensive and not that great. Further, if you take a boat over to the island, be prepared for motion sickness, even if you are use to boats. That isn't related to the hotel exactly, but you should know ahead of time (we didn't).