Expert Opinion
I have stayed at the Riverside Lodge somewhere between 20 and 30 times over the last 30 years so therefore, I would say the I am an expert on this property.
First of all, book as early as you can. The Riverside is probably the most popular place to stay in town and the choice rooms tend to book up pretty quick.
Over the years, there have been many additions to the cabins so some are newer than others. I prefer a free standing cabin as opposed to a lodge type room so I don't have to listen to my upstairs neighbors walk around. My favorite 2 bedroom single story cabins are 16, 17, and 7. The two story condo units are much newer and nicer but more expensive, but I think that they may be worth the extra money. One of the bedrooms on all of the two story units has a balcony that overlooks the mountains to the north. It's very nice to sit out and watch deer and elk in the mornings and evenings.
Most if not all cabins have a covered porch with old timey metal lawn chairs so you can sit out and enjoy the fresh air. The building furthest to the east was once called the "New Lodge". I don't know if they still call it that or not, but it was built in the early to mid 80's. These are some of the newer nicer rooms, but they are all in one building, and that kind of kills the atmosphere for me. When I go to the mountains I want to stay in a cabin...not a hotel.
The property is well kept and has some nice features. A hot tub, Horseshoes, shuffleboard, a party room, and a playground for small children are all centrally located.
Now for the bad. The towels are pretty small and thin. I assume that this is done on purpose to keep you from stealing them, but you can barely get dried off with one.
From year to year, there are different people running the desk. I have for the most part found them to be courteous, but I have had my issues with them on occasion. I remind them that I have spent thousands of dollars over the years staying there, and that I expect more from them and that normally resolves the issue.
As one of the reviewers mentioned, I have seen some things that didn't work in my rooms before. I didn't let it spoil my trip though, and if it was something important or dangerous, I would nicely ask them to do something about it and they normally would take care of it.
Most of the properties in Red River book up every week so they have what I would call a captive audience. You may stay here and love it or you may stay here and wish you hadn't. The problem as I see it is that boycotting one or the other doesn't do any good. They are going to be full regardless. I hope you find my review informative.