Ask This Question Before You Book
The best thing about the Islander is the location, one of the few places you can stay in the Keys that is not on the noisy highway. The worst thing about the Islander, at least in June, is that they have may be having one or even several wedding parties going on. (Four on the Saturday we were there.) This makes for a lot of noise at night. I mean unbearably loud! Also, while the pools are beautiful, the room we stayed in was in desperate need of refurbishing, with broken blinds that wouldn't even close and stained walls in kitchen area and bath. Ugh! As the keys go (and much is worn and rustic here), the Islander is one of the better places to stay, but whatever you do, ask how many wedding parties will be going on while you're there or you may not get much rest.
