they lost my ring and won't pay for it
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 1/12/11
On December 15-18, 2010 we stayed at the Newport Beach Hotel & Suites.
Two hours after checking out, on our way back to our home state of NJ, I realized I had left my ring in our room. I promptly called the hotel front desk and spoke with Emily whom, after checking with Housekeeping, said they did indeed have the ring in their possession. She requested and received my credit card information to ship the ring back to me immediately. I patiently waited two weeks but no one called and I did not receive anything in the mail. After 2 weeks, I called and inquired about the ring. Emily immediately referred me to Phil Fonte, general manager with no explanation. He stated this was the first he heard of the ring and informed me the hotel had lost the ring after logging it in their paperwork. He had no explanation as to what happened and informed me the hotel accepted responsibility as it was in their possession at the time of the loss. He stated the only thing he was prepared to do, with proper documentation of the ring's value, was refund our hotel stay but not address reparation of the value of the ring. We were unhappy with this reply so my husband emailed the heads of the Newport Hotel group.
I then received a phone call from Phil Forte again requesting documentation of the ring's value before hotel negotiations would proceed. I faxed over a receipt of the ring's $900 value as well an appraisal provided by the seller. Phil Forte promptly called me stating since i rejected their offer of refund of our stay (less than half the ring's value) they are taking back that offer and not offering anything.
I cannot express how extremely upsetting this whole situation is. We were hoping for a wonderful getaway in a family friendly town where businesses truly valued their customers. Instead, this has turned into a highly stressful situation with a business not offering any explanation or reparation for a customer's ring they admitted was in their possession. I cannot rule out the possibility of a crime being committed in that my ring has been stolen and the hotel management is not being cooperative.