Go to the Monheagan House!
Although the Island Inn is always known for being wonderful and relaxing, I would recommend somewhere else. The Island Inn does not go with the ambiance of the island. It's huge and I personally think it's rather ugly. While most of the island is rustic and old-timey, the Island Inn is a tourist trap. Go to the Monhegan House, or rent a cottage!
Thank you for reporting abuse on this Yahoo Travel review.
We appreciate your input and will resolve the issue as soon as possible.
By notifying us of the abuse, you're helping to ensure a quality experience for other Yahoo Travel users just like you.